Hi, virtual wanderers who ended up here in Wonderland for some reason unknown! Welcome! :D
It's good to see you guys here!
So... I know this post's title will cause some polemic... I already feel it.
Well, the other day I was in my English Literature Club (I think you can call it like that - anyways, I'm not going anymore, unfortunatelly...) and we somehow started this discussion about Twilight. The teacher and the other students were all against the series, saying they'd rather watch paint dry than watch one of the movies and stuff... They were talking like if there was only bad in Stephenie Meyer's work.
I am not a "fan" of the series. I criticize it lots, specially as a writer. I see many flaws in it. But you have to look for the good things too! I have all the books, have read all at least twice each (except for The Brief Second Life of Bree Tanner, which I only read once and didn't feel like reading again... ever). Have watched all the movies, too - the first three, I watched twice each. So, yeah, I criticize a lot, but can't say I don't like it. So I stood up in Twilight's defense... And ended up having to write an essay on Why you should give Twilight a second look. And since many of my friends are interested on reading... I'll just publish it here and see what happens. Please, comment! Let the debate begin... Hahah! :P
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WHY YOU SHOULD GIVE TWILIGHT
A SECOND LOOK
To hate on Twilight
is a trend now. Even people who have never read a single line of it or watched
a single movie talk bad about it, going with the flow. But let us be rational
about this: it is a best-seller for a reason. I mean, the series might not be
the best in the world — far, very far from that — , but it has its merits. So
let us analyze this.
Everyone knows the story. An utterly uninteresting
girl called Bella Swan moves to a small town, where she is now going to live
with her father. She goes to school and falls in love with Edward Cullen, the
most “perfect” guy of the town. Surprisingly, he corresponds to that love and
right after the girl finds out he is a vampire. That brings many problems to
the couple and we have the complication of Jacob Black, Bella’s best friend
that is also in love with her. He happens to be a werewolf — member of a tribe of
enemies of the vampires. We have then a love triangle. In the end, Bella
chooses Edward over Jacob and marries him. Summing things up, that’s it. So,
what is so special about that story that has lead millions of people all around
the world to read it?
To answer that question, we have to make some
reflections on what Literature is. More specifically, we have to answer another
question: what is Literature here for? Of course, Literature is a form of art,
so it should not have to be “useful” — being
should be enough for it. But in our utilitarian society we measure the value of
everything according to its utility, to the benefit or the advantage it can
give us. So, following that line, what is Literature useful for?
Well, the art of the words has changed through
history, and so did its function. Literature has served many purposes: we have
written to remember, to protest, to denounce, to entertain, to inform, to
contain rebellions and to create rebellions. We have written to affirm, to
convince, to deny; to build and to destroy. And at all those moments, the
utility given to Literature reflected the needs of the society it has
originated from. In our time, we can sum up the Literature’s function in one
word: escapism.
What does that mean? It means that nowadays’ books
have all this one goal: to give people a way to escape from reality. Give them
somewhere to go when they do not want to be where they are. As a proof of that,
we have the growth of two genres that are the absolute majority in our book
store shelves: supernatural and self-help. Supernatural stories literally
transport the reader to a completely different — more magical and more pleasing
— reality, whilst self-help books help people dealing with the cruel real
world, when they cannot escape from it.
So that is the main “utility” of Literature in this
early XXI century. And what does that have to do with Twilight? The answer is quite obvious: what Meyer has actually done
was writing a typical book of our time. Pertaining to the supernatural genre,
it matches all the characteristics of the literary movement of our time, which
I like to call Escapism or Supernaturalism.
Before answering our title question, let us think of
another important point: who was Twilight
written for? As a wannabe writer, there is one thing I can tell you for sure:
it is impossible for a person to write without having an ideal reader in mind.
Of course you want everyone to read your text, but you have to keep in mind
that it is going to be more interesting to a certain profile of reader — and
you have to keep your eyes on that reader. So, who was Stephenie Meyer’s target
public?
It is not hard to figure out: the series was written
for women. Actually, for girls: young teenagers around their 13-15 years old. I
myself read the series for the first time when I was that age. It was at the
maximum point of its success, all my friends were reading. And all liked it
back then, even though some now criticize it. So, when you are thinking of
Literature, trying to ponder its value — yeah, let us just pretend that is
possible —, you cannot forget this: it was written specifically for someone. And
if you are not that “someone”, chances are you are not going to like it,
personally. But that does not mean the book is necessarily bad. It only has not
fallen into the right reader’s hands.
“And what are the ‘merits’ of Twilight?”, my impatient reader must be asking. Here goes your
answer: the series meet the needs of its ideal readers.
Because every young girl can somehow find herself in
Bella — that is called identification
and, according to American mythologist Joseph Campbell, it is the most
important process that can occur within the self of a reader or listener while
following a story.
The teenager girl of our time is always insecure about
herself. Some are more insecure, some are less, but all have their doubts, even
if they are hidden behind a strong personality. Bella is what you can call an
“insecurity cluster”: she holds all types of fears a girl can have. She is not
beautiful, she is not clever, she is not special at all. She is just average. So
she worries: “Do I look well enough?”, “Will any guy ever like me?”, “Am I a
nice person people will want as a friend?”
But with Bella’s story what we learn is: the right guy
will like you, in spite of anything.
You can be just normal and still, if the love is true, he won’t care. To his
eyes, you are going to be beautiful and nice and everything you think you are
not. It might seem ridiculous to some, but to the young girl who is reading the
series that is important. A lot.
“What a silly girl is that, to need a story like Twilight to help her with her — lack of —
self-esteem”, one might say. But that need is not a problem or a shame to that
girl and we should not make fun of her. It is just a normal phase of her growth
and she will very soon find herself. And to be honest even fully grown up women
have to face that same insecurities at times. That is what society does to us.
(And that is why adult women like Twilight too — and it is totally ok.)
So why should
you give Twilight a second look?
Because you should look at it with the eyes of its target readers. To those
young girls, the series is perfect because it is exactly what they need. Edward
and Jacob make them believe, make them hope… Make them dream. And at their age,
dreaming might at times be everything they have. Everything they know. So it is
good that they have that for them. At the very end, that is what life is all
about: dreaming.
Andressa Andrade
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
P.S.: Please, forgive any grammar/spelling mistakes... English is not my native language, so sometimes things can go wrong, lol.